All-Stars
| YEAR | LOCATION | GAME SCORES | MVP | TEAM |
| 2016 | Oil City Stadium, Whiting, Indiana | South 7 – 6 South 15 – 2 South 6 – 2 |
Kenton Crews-Heritage Hills High School | |
| 2015 | Warn Field Terre Haute, Indiana |
North 10 – 6 North 11 – 8 |
Clay Dungan -Yorktown High School | Roster |
| 2014 | John Cate Field Richmond, Indiana |
South 7 – 3 South 9 – 7 South 12 – 9 |
Tyler Houston – Brownsburg High School |
|
| 2013 | Wabash College | South 7 – 3 South 13 – 0 South 3 – 1 |
Alex Krupa – Greenwood HS |
Roster |
| 2012 | Alvin C. Ruxer Field Jasper, Indiana |
North 4 – 3 North 14 – 10 South 2 – 1 |
Gabe Acevedo – Portage High School |
|
| 2011 | Parkview Field Ft. Wayne, Indiana |
North 6 – 3 South 14 – 3 South 10 – 3 |
A.J. Reed – Terre Haute South HS |
Roster |
| 2010 | John Cate Field McBride Stadium Richmond, Indiana |
South 9 – 3 North 9 – 7 South 12 – 8 |
Tyler Wampler – West Vigo HS |
Roster |
| 2009 | Braun Stadium Bosse USI Baseball Field Evansville, IN |
North 15 – 5 North 11 – 4 North 3 – 2 |
Brandon Elliott – Plymouth |
Roster |
| 2008 | Notre Dame’s Frank Eck Stadium | South 16 – 8 North 7 – 4 South 3 – 0 |
Cody Johnson – North Harrison |
Roster |
| 2007 | Huntington University | North 3 – 0 North 5 – 3 North 7 – 2 |
Garrett Seagraves – Lewis Cass HS |
Roster |
| 2006 | Rose Hulman Univ. Art Nehf Field |
South 7-6 North 13-6 South 6-2 |
Josh Phegley – Terre Haute North |
Roster |
| 2005 | Valparaiso/Gary | South 7-3 South 4-3 North 9-3 |
Jason Jamerson – Pendelton Heights High School |
Roster |
| 2004 | Jasper | North 8-4 North 11-6 South 5-4 rain |
Mike Ryan – Andrean High School |
Roster |
| 2003 | Indiana Tech Ft. Wayne |
North 6-4 South 11-10 North 2-1 |
Jose Mendez – Lake Central |
Roster |
| 2002 | Lambert Field, Purdue University |
South 8-1 North 5-3 North 13-8 |
Drew Kochert – McCutcheon High School |
Roster |
| 2001 | Butler University, Indianapolis, IN | North 6-5 South 10-1 Game 3 Rained out |
Dave Zachary – Penn High School |
Roster |
| 2000 | Ft. Wayne | North 3-2 South 4-3 South 10-3 |
Brett Garrard – Brownsburg |
Roster |
| 1999 | Plymouth | South 12-2 South 8-2 South 8-5 |
Bryan Bullington – Madison |
Roster |
| 1998 | Evansville | South 13-3 North 12-5 South 9-8 |
Scott French – Shakamak |
Roster |
| 1997 | Indiana Wesleyan | North 9-8 North 12-6 South 5-3 |
Chris Bootcheck – LaPorte |
Roster |
| 1996 | Jasper | North 9-6 North 9-5 North 13-6 |
Brian Stultz – S. Bend Riley |
Roster |
| 1995 | Indiana University | North 8-7 North 18-11 South 6-5 |
Ben Witzenmen – Ft. Wayne Concordia |
Roster |
| 1994 | Ball State University | North 7-0 North 4-3 South 7-3 |
Tate Lane – S. Bend Washington |
Roster |
| 1993 | Richmond | South 9-9 North 6-4 South 6-3 |
Phil White – Richmond |
Roster |
| 1992 | Huntington College | North 4-0 South 2-1 North 7-4 rain |
Steve Carter – Elkhart Memorial |
Roster |
| 1991 | Indiana State UniversityTerre Haute | South 10-8 North 6-4 South 5-2 |
Shannon Stigleman – Jay County |
Roster |
| 1990 | Purdue University | North 17-13 South 10-0 North 1-0 |
Brad Rubsam – Evansville Memorial |
Roster |
| 1989 | South Bend | North 10-9 South 3-2 South 4-3 |
Matt Riggs – Yorktown |
Roster |
| 1988 | Ball State University | South 8-4 South 7-2 South 10-7 |
John Smith – North Central |
Roster |
| 1987 | Jasper | South 2-0 South 8-7 South 10-4 |
Brad Tyler – South Dearborn |
Roster |
| 1986 | Kokomo | North 7-6 South 6-2 North 8-1 |
Chris Boyer – Penn |
Roster |
| 1985 | Anderson College | North 5-4 South 10-9 North 7-5 |
Rob Barber – Jennings County |
Roster |
| 1984 | LaPorte | North 8-0 South 8-7 extra North 3-2 extra |
Brent Wolff – South Bend Clay |
Roster |
| 1983 | Jasper | North 7-4 South 4-2 South 10-3 |
Bill Baker – Shelbyville |
Roster |
| 1982 | Indiana State UniversityTerre Haute | North 3-1 North 6-4 South 6-5 |
Jay Grate – East Noble |
Roster |
| 1981 | Lafayette | South 2-0 North 2-1 Game 3 Rained out |
Mike Humphrey – New Albany |
Roster |
| 1980 | Jasper | North 8-3 South 14-4 South 8-7 extra |
None | Roster |
| 1979 | Jasper | North 6-1 North 6-4 North 10-8 |
None | Roster |
| 1978 | LaPorte | South 6-0 North 6-4 North 4-3 |
None | Roster |
| 1977 | Jasper | North 2-0 North 4-2 extra North 4-0 |
None | Roster |
| 1976 | South Bend Clay | North 5-3 South 7-6 North 5-2 |
None | Roster |
| 1975 | Bush Stadium Indianapolis |
North 5-3 North 7-0 |
None | Roster |
